• Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Try for $2! Not Too Hot Sauce
  • Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce Not Too Hot Sauce
  • Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Try for $2! Not Too Hot Sauce
  • Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Try for $2! Not Too Hot Sauce
  • Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Try for $2! Not Too Hot Sauce
  • Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Try for $2! Not Too Hot Sauce
  • Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Not Too Hot Sauce

Creamy Buff-alo 7 oz. Buffalo Sauce - Try for $2!

Regular price

PLEASE NOTE: Because we offer this product at such a deep discount, each new customer can only purchase up to one of each flavor or one Variety Pack at this price. You may still add additional full price bottles if you would like to stock up!

Buffalo sauce perfected! Creamy and zingy with a kick you can handle, our Creamy Buff-alo has everything you crave from this wing night favorite. Our cayenne-based sauce is tempered with tomato for a softer kick that works perfectly as a classic wing sauce.

  • Ingredients: Distilled vinegar, cayenne pepper puree, canola oil, water, tomatoes, rocoto pepper puree, egg yolk, citric acid, xanthan gum, garlic powder, annatto
  • Pair With: Wings, fries, sandwiches (as a spread), or use as a dipping sauce

    Heat Level

    The heat level of our Creamy Buff-alo is slightly milder than most standard buffalo sauces with a creamy finish - imagine if Chik-fil-A's Zesty Buffalo Sauce and Frank's Red Hot had a baby.

      Extra Mild 40%
      Super Hot 60%

      Dietary Restrictions

      • Gluten free

      • Dairy free

      • Soy free

      • Nut free

      Why You'll Love It

      • The absolute best buffalo flavor on the market

      • Perfect thickness that sticks to your food

      • Real, natural ingredients you can see in the bottle

      • Perfect punch of heat that won't knock you out

      • Better taste than big box brands

      • Dairy free recipe and silky smooth texture

      What Makes Not Too Hot Sauce Special

      - The boldest flavors on the market

      - Crafted in small batches with passion and fresh ingredients

      - Guaranteed quality and consistency in every bottle

      - Mild and medium options with consistent heat level labeling

      - Made in the USA by a woman-owned business

      - Gluten free, soy free, dairy free to suit most diets

      - Perfect for gifting with attractive packaging